Marketing Hiring in Q4: Plenty of Candidates, Very Few "Perfect" Ones

>5mins

Marketing has no talent shortage this quarter. There is an oversupply of candidates across t...

Marketing has no talent shortage this quarter. There is an oversupply of candidates across the market, and candidates report that finding the right opportunity is competitive and slow. Yet clients are still struggling to hire, because what they are searching for is narrower than the market can supply.

The Shortage Is of Precise Fit, Not of Marketers

Clients are focused on hiring the "perfect" candidate, and the definition has four parts: the right time to move, a logical motivation for moving, a direct industry or product background, and a specialist skill base. Each criterion removes candidates from the pool, and together they can reduce a crowded market to a handful of people. Hiring managers who list all four as essential should expect long searches, however many applications arrive.

The hot skills list shows where that precision bites hardest: go-to-market, growth and demand generation, and senior or strategic marketing leads and heads of marketing. These are specialist and senior profiles, not generalist ones. At the other end, content generation, generalist marketing executives, and marketing administrators are all well supplied. The practical lesson is to separate what a role genuinely requires from what is simply desirable. A brief that demands direct product experience for a role where transferable commercial skills would do will filter out candidates who could succeed.

Clients Flex for the Perfect Candidate, Candidates Want a Strong Financial Reason

The salary standoff follows directly from this. Clients have shown some flexibility, and base salaries offered are rising slightly above the original bracket, but only for the "perfect" candidate, typically one coming from a competitor or a similar industry or product. For everyone else, the bracket holds.

Candidates see it differently. When approached through InMail, the feedback is often that the salaries quoted are too low, and candidates are reluctant to move without a strong financial benefit, in the range of a €10,000 to €15,000 increase on their current base. A bracket that flexes slightly for an ideal candidate is a long way from a move of that size, which explains why so many conversations stall.

Base salary is not the whole offer, though. Candidates want a well-rounded package: equity, a car allowance, a high level of annual leave, and paid health insurance, alongside the salary. For employers who cannot close the gap on base pay, these elements are the practical alternative, and candidates are clearly weighing them.

Flexibility Is a Priority, and Volume Is Hiding Poor Fit

For marketing profiles, hybrid working is a firm expectation. Candidates look for a maximum of three days a week in the office, with two days the norm, and flexibility is treated as a priority benefit. Employers asking for more should expect resistance.

This quarter's clearest example came from a client that advertised a role directly and was swamped with applicants. With a one-button apply process, the volume was easy to generate and impossible to manage properly, and the client came to us for help. It highlights the oversupply of candidates, and it shows that an easy application route produces quantity at the expense of relevance.

There is a second problem inside that volume. Candidates are using AI to apply for roles and to reformat their CVs to match the job description. This is now routine practice, part of how applications are produced at scale. When we screen those candidates, many lack the market experience and skill base the role requires. The CVs are over-tailored: they mirror the job description closely, but the substance behind them is missing. For hiring managers, a CV that reads as a perfect match is no longer proof of one, and screening has to test for experience directly.

The Takeaway

In marketing, the challenge is not finding applicants but finding the right ones, and that takes a realistic brief, a package that gives candidates a clear reason to move, and screening that looks past a polished CV. Get in touch with our team for custom benchmarking on the marketing roles proving hardest to fill in your business.